Artika Countersues Signify Over Philips Hue Patents

Artika countersues Signify

Artika Countersues Signify, Targeting Philips Hue Technology

The Signify–Artika patent dispute now runs in both directions. In a new development, Artika countersues Signify.

Artika for Living Inc. has denied Signify’s infringement allegations and filed counterclaims accusing Signify of infringing two Artika patents through Philips Hue smart lighting products.

The 48-page response, filed 23 October 2026, targets technology involving wireless lighting control and firmware updates. Artika seeks damages, a permanent injunction, and attorneys’ fees.

The filing comes in Signify North America Corporation and Signify Holding B.V. v. Artika for Living Inc., Case No. 2:26-cv-00653-JRG, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division.

These are Artika’s allegations and defenses. The filing does not establish that either company infringed the other’s patents.

From Defendant to Counterclaimant

EdisonReport reported on Signify’s original lawsuit in August. Signify accused Artika of infringing six patents covering configurable lighting, LED power control, driver technology, and modular LED light engines.

Artika’s response challenges those claims while introducing a separate infringement case against Signify within the same lawsuit.

The Canadian manufacturer asserts ownership of two U.S. patents:

  • U.S. Patent No. 10,582,595
  • U.S. Patent No. 10,085,330

Both carry the title Light Bulb, Intelligent Lighting Device and Method and System for Use in Configuring Same.

Artika alleges that certain Philips Hue products use the patented technology without authorization. Its examples include a Philips Hue White and Color Ambiance bulb and a Hue starter kit containing a Bridge and two E26 smart bulbs.

Wireless Control and Firmware Updates Take Center Stage

The technical allegations focus on how smart lighting devices receive commands and software updates.

For the ’595 patent, Artika identifies claim 1. That claim describes an intelligent lighting device with a programmable controller, stored firmware, and two different wireless communication interfaces.

Artika argues that the accused Hue bulbs meet those requirements through their Zigbee and Bluetooth capabilities. According to the counterclaim, Bluetooth carries lighting commands, while Zigbee delivers firmware updates that modify lighting behavior.

To support its position, Artika cites product specifications, chip documentation, and Hue software release notes.

Those release notes describe updates adding lighting effects, changing dynamic scenes, and introducing color-temperature controls. Artika contends that these updates correspond to elements of its patent claim.

That is Artika’s proposed connection between the technology and the patent. Whether the accused products satisfy every required claim element remains an issue for the case.

The Hue Bridge Is Also a Target

The second counterclaim centers on claim 16 of the ’330 patent.

That claim concerns an auxiliary device used to configure an intelligent light bulb. Artika identifies the Hue Bridge as that device.

According to the filing, the Bridge receives update information from Signify’s cloud services and transmits firmware updates to connected bulbs over Zigbee. Artika argues that this process falls within its patent’s requirements.

The company also alleges indirect infringement. It points to Signify’s marketing, instructions, technical support, and other materials that encourage customers to use the accused features.

Although the filing references several Signify brands in its background discussion, its detailed infringement allegations focus on Philips Hue products.

Artika Says It Notified Signify in 2025

The counterclaims introduce another element to the companies’ licensing history.

Artika alleges that it notified Signify in writing on 3 June 2025, that certain Signify LED products used Artika’s patented technology. It says that letter specifically identified the ’595 patent and Philips Hue bulbs.

Artika further alleges that Signify continued infringing after receiving notice and refused to license Artika’s patents.

Those assertions add a competing account to the dispute. Signify’s original complaint described years of efforts to license its own patents to Artika. Now, Artika says Signify also faced a licensing request.

The filing does not resolve either company’s account of those discussions.

Artika Denies Infringing Signify’s Six Patents

On the defense side, Artika denies infringement across all six patents Signify asserted.

The response identifies the Artika products at issue, including the Maelstrom and Coda pendants, Alton flush mount, Essence Flare, Essence Bar pendant, and Altitude flush mount. Artika acknowledges selling or offering those products but denies that they infringe.

It also acknowledges receiving correspondence and participating in presentations, calls, and a Montreal meeting with Signify.

However, Artika rejects the suggestion that its knowledge of Signify’s allegations—or its decision not to accept a license—establishes infringement or willfulness.

Its defenses include noninfringement, invalidity, lack of standing, and limits on damages. Artika also raises license and patent exhaustion defenses, among others.

These are asserted defenses, not court rulings.

What Artika Wants From the Court

Artika asks the court to dismiss Signify’s complaint with prejudice and find the asserted patent claims invalid and not infringed.

On its own counterclaims, Artika seeks:

  • A judgment that Signify infringes the two Artika patents.
  • A permanent injunction against further infringement.
  • Damages of at least a reasonable royalty, plus interest.
  • Attorneys’ fees and costs under an exceptional-case finding.

Artika also demands a jury trial on its counterclaims.

For lighting manufacturers following this dispute, the significant development is clear: Artika is pursuing its own patent claims alongside its defense. The case now places both companies’ technology and patent positions under scrutiny.

Go Deeper