DOLED Comments on POE

 Brodrick 2016 LFI.jpgA New Report on the Energy Reporting Capability of PoE Connected Lighting Systems

Connected lighting systems that can report their own energy consumption can deliver increased energy savings over conventional lighting solutions by facilitating data-driven energy management. Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology —  in which a single Ethernet cable is used to both provide low-voltage DC power and enable network communication —  has the potential to bring this capability to mainstream lighting applications and has become increasingly viable for LED lighting, which is why it’s the focus of a great deal of industry attention. However, at the present time, PoE is an unfamiliar concept to traditional lighting users.

DOE has just published the first part of a study to explore the energy reporting capability of commercially marketed PoE connected lighting systems. The new report provides a brief background on the development of the various PoE technologies, ranging from standards-based to proprietary, and illustrates the convergence of PoE power sourcing capabilities and LED luminaire power requirements. It then classifies PoE system devices in relationship to how they’re used in systems —  introducing clarifying terminology as needed —  and briefly describes different PoE system architectures implemented by various lighting manufacturers. A discussion of existing standards and specifications that address energy reporting is provided, and existing test setups and methods germane to characterizing PoE system energy reporting performance are reviewed.

The report concludes with a number of recommendations for various industry stakeholders, aimed at accelerating the development and deployment of energy reporting PoE connected lighting systems. Among the recommendations:
  • Some minimum level of detail describing where, when, and how energy is reported by commercially available PoE lighting systems should be developed and adopted by manufacturers and technology providers. Industry might develop such detail as a recommended practice, perhaps with assistance from DOE.
  • Recommended practices should be developed to limit energy loss in PoE cables, especially for installations where they’re not explicitly reported. DOE is considering a study to characterize the impact of cable and connector losses on example PoE system architectures, and to verify that any developed recommended practices achieve their stated goal.
  • Some minimum level of detail describing how energy is reported by PoE lighting devices and systems should be developed and adopted by manufacturers and technology providers. This detail should include energy reporting performance, including accuracy and precision, as characterized per industry standards and specifications. Standards or specifications describing test setups, test methods, and performance classes suitable for characterizing the energy reporting performance claims of PoE and other connected lighting devices and systems should be developed as necessary, so that competing claims (e.g., for different devices and systems, or from different manufacturers) can be easily and fairly compared. 
  • PoE stakeholders who are experienced in the characterization of energy reporting performance should contribute to any test setups and methods included in standards and specifications being developed by appropriate organizations. Stakeholders who might use energy data should contribute to any performance classes included in standards and specifications being developed by appropriate organizations. DOE is currently engaged in this work. 
  • Lighting industry stakeholders should encourage standard and specification development organizations to coordinate existing and new activities, consolidate competing activities, minimize overlap, and otherwise strive to develop test setups, methods, and performance classes for characterizing energy reporting performance that are appropriate for PoE and other lighting devices and systems.
DOE welcomes your feedback, as well as any suggestions you might have for other studies; send your comments to [email protected].

For complete details, download the full report.
Best regards, 
Jim Brodrick